Anglicanism & the U.S. Episcopal Church

For a breakdown in Anglicanism vs. the U.S. Episcopal Church — you'll see why they’re not quite the same thing even though they’re related, and how theyre similar to Catholicism. 

✅ Anglicanism (worldwide)

Anglicanism is a global tradition, (not a single denomination like what Americans are used to understanding as one clear cut denomination with one clear belief statement and one clear teaching on core beliefs [and clear secondary views, which set them apart from other denominations].

Anglicanism includes churches in the Anglican Communion, all tracing their roots to the Church of England.

Because it’s broad, Anglicanism includes:

• High church / Anglo-Catholic groups (very “Catholic-like”) 😬

• Low church / evangelical groups (more “Protestant-like”)😊

• Broad church groups (middle, more liberal)😬

So know Anglicanism contains a range of theological identities. Not clear cut, not all are true Christian/biblical. 

🇺🇸 How U.S. Anglicanism developed

Before the American Revolution, the Church of England existed in the colonies.

After independence, American Anglicans formed:

The Episcopal Church (TEC)

The first official Anglican body in the U.S., formed in the late 1700s.

For over 200 years, the Episcopal Church was the U.S. Anglican church in the Anglican Communion.

How the Episcopal Church differs from broader Anglicanism

1. Governance

• They uses a bicameral General Convention (House of Bishops + House of Deputies).

• Laity and clergy "vote on doctrine" (😬), liturgy, discipline.

• Generally more democratic than many Anglican provinces.

2. Theology & practice

Compared to global Anglicanism, the Episcopal Church tends to be:

➤ ⚠️ More liberal / progressive theologically

Examples:

• Ordination of women (1976)

• Open LGBTQ+ inclusion

• Blessing and marriage of same-sex couples

• Very open stance on social and political issues

• Culture focused, not Biblically focused. *[Culture, is based on unsaved sinners worldviews]

Global Anglicanism includes more conservative provinces (e.g., Africa, Asia), but this means theyre on the “progressive” end of the spectrum. Sounds confusing, I know. 

*See comparison chart below on how these groups/sects/splinter "faiths" beliefs oppose biblical truths and clear teachings. 

➤ Still allows Anglo-Catholic, evangelical, and broad church parishes

But the overall national direction is more "progressive".

3. Relationship to the Anglican Communion

The Episcopal Church is still part of the Anglican Communion, though sometimes in tension with other provinces over theology and sexuality.

What about other U.S. Anglican groups?

Because of disagreements with the Episcopal Church, other Anglican bodies formed, such as:

The Anglican Church in North America (ACNA) (2009)*

• More conservative

• Does not bless same-sex marriages

• Often more evangelical or traditional

• Not officially part of the Anglican Communion, but in relationship with many conservative Anglican provinces.

So today, U.S. Anglicanism includes:

• TEC; Episcopal Church branch- progressive, official Anglican Communion member

• ACNA – conservative*, not officially recognized by the Archbishop of Canterbury

• Smaller Anglican bodies (Reformed* Episcopal Church, APA, etc.)

Below is a clean, simple, and direct comparison of the three groups 

• High-Church / Anglo-Catholic

• Broad-Church

• Biblical Christianity 

It describes how each relates to the essentials of Christianity and the Gospel message (as typically summarized through a sin → judgment → repentance → faith → Christ-alone framework).

⭐ 1. Biblical Christianity:

View of Scripture

• Scripture alone is the final, infallible authority.

• All doctrine, ethics, and worship are normed by the Bible.

View of Sin

• Sin is personal, universal, and morally guilty before a holy God.

• Humans are spiritually dead apart from divine grace.

• Sin is rebellion, not merely brokenness.

View of Christ

• Fully God, fully man.

• Born of the virgin Mary.

• Lived a sinless life.

• Died a substitutionary death.

• Rose bodily.

• Exclusive Savior.

View of the Cross / Atonement

Central emphasis:

• Penal substitution: Christ bore God’s righteous judgment in the sinner’s place.

• Salvation is only through His finished work.

• Justification is by grace through faith alone.

View of Salvation

• Not through sacraments, works, nor moral improvement.

Solely by: 

• God’s grace

• repentance

• personal faith in Christ

• Born Again by God/New birth (regeneration), which is the instant ine time work of the Holy Spirit.

• Good works flow from salvation, not into it.

Gospel Presentation

Typically:

• God is holy.

• Humans are sinners under judgment.

• Christ lived, died, and rose to save sinners.

• Repent and believe for forgiveness.

• Salvation is by grace alone, through faith alone, in Christ alone.

Overall

Atonement-centered, repentance-centered, and Scripture-centered understanding of the Gospel and essentials of Christianity.

✅️These are very important to know and memorize so false churches sects and groups dont decieve you. 

 2. Anglo-Catholic/ High-Church

⚠️View of Scripture

Scripture is authoritative, BUT (not really, cuz) interpreted through the lens of: 

• church tradition

• liturgy

• sacramental theology

• “Scripture [God's Word] as the final and only infallible authority” in the biblical Christian sense, is not usually their view.

⚠️View of Sin

• Holds a real doctrine of sin, original sin, and human fallenness.

• Humans truly need redemption.

⚠️View of Christ

Affirms: 

• full deity

• full humanity

• virgin birth

• bodily resurrection

• ascension

Appears orthodox Christology, but in their teachings shows theyre holding to an idolatrous jesus. 👉False teachers accept some truths about Jesus but distort other truths [even world religions do]. 

⚠️View of the Cross / Atonement

• Christ saves sinners.

• The cross is essential.

But the emphasis is usually on: 

• Christus Victor(1)

• the healing power of the incarnation

• sacramental participation in Christ’s life

• Penal substitution (Christ bearing wrath for sin) may be accepted, downplayed, or avoided depending on the church/parish.

• Basically: Jesus work is not sufficient to save, people must "do things" (sacraments) and works "to contribute". 

⚠️View of Salvation

Grace comes through Christ, BUT normally mediated "through" sacraments: 

• baptism

• Eucharist

• confession

• Salvation is often seen as a lifelong incorporation into Christ through worship, sacrament, and discipline rather than at "a decisive decision" aka conversion. 

>>>>This is works based religion.

-They have a wrong understanding of Grace, Salvation and Jesus. 

⚠️Gospel Presentation

• Usually not the biblical one: “law→conviction→repentance→faith that trusts in Christs full & finished work” .

Emphasis is on: 

• sacramental union with Christ

• following the liturgical year

• spiritual formation

Their cooperative system "adds to" biblical truth; unnecessary mediating steps that adds to the finished work of Christ. Scripture always says use discernment, know the Word, do not proclaim a false gospel, & point to the true Christ. They fail here. 

Overall

Seem Orthodox on some doctrines, but is sacramental rather than on how salvation is experienced and explained in Scripture.

Btw High church doesnt mean more holy. It is simply a phrase used by them that may to try to imply it, deveptively. 

3. Broad-Church Anglicanism /"middle" mixed

(This is a diverse category—some are very orthodox, others very liberal.)

⚠️View of Scripture

Scripture is valued, BUT often interpreted with greater emphasis on: 

• reason

• experience

• modern insights

• Some clergy hold full biblical authority; others treat Scripture as a theological witness, not a binding revelation.

⚠️View of Sin

Often reframed as: 

• brokenness

• injustice

• lack of human flourishing

• Less emphasis on: 

• personal guilt

• divine wrath

• judgment

• Few focus on sin as rebellion or depravity.

⚠️View of Christ

Ranges widely:

• Many affirm historic doctrine.

• Some reinterpret, or mythologize (aka are symbolic rather than literal), the

 miracles, resurrection, or exclusivity of Christ.

⚠️View of the Cross / Atonement

Very mixed: 

• Some accept substitution.

• Many prefer moral-example or Christus Victor.

• Some reject penal substitution outright.

⚠️View of Salvation

Can range from: 

• classic Christian salvation

• inclusivism (“Christ saves people in other religions”)

• universalism (“God saves everyone”)

⚠️Gospel Presentation

Often:

• ethical

• social-renewal focused

• emphasizes community, justice, healing

rather than on what Scripture revealed as repentance and personal faith in Christ for forgiveness.

They preach a false gospel.

Overall

Highly varied. Some Broad-Church parishes hold the Gospel faithfully, others reinterpret or minimize core doctrines to suit their worldview and are not biblical (true church/es). 

Insert 💥💥💥💥

Many of these are outside true Christianity and it is hard to (simply) know which one they are. And even if *you* truly understand it, your kids won't, and they’ll likely end up in a false church later on cuz its too confusing and they assume any church that calls itself a church is a church.... which is far from the truth. Or any church calling themselves Anglican is all the same/biblical- it's not. So, BEST to avoid them, and just stay in go to a normal biblical church within real Christian denominations. They hold to biblical truth. 

*It isnt that there's slight differences. Theyre huge; it's that [the false ones] their differences run right up against what God in Scripture has clearly revealed. They choose idolatry (falsehoods) over truth, and adjust it to suit their sins. They preach a diff Gospel than the one in Scripture, thus a diff god and jesus. They trample the truth to cling to distortions. They are not of God. Like Satan who is able to present as an angel of light, so are those children of his who are decieved and decieve with subtle demonic doctrines, "making folk twice the sons of Hell they themselves are". 

Any group that alters the Gospel is to be avoided. The Essentials are directly connected to the Gospel. To true Christianity. Believers really really need to grasp this well.  

<<< return to prev pg 

Go To 

Jump to Resources for Believers